For a market impact model, price manipulation and related notions play a role
that is similar to the role of arbitrage in a derivatives pricing model. Here,
we give a systematic investigation into such regularity issues when orders can
be executed both at a traditional exchange and in a dark pool. To this end, we
focus on a class of dark-pool models whose market impact at the exchange is
described by an Almgren--Chriss model.
We derive explicit recursive formulas for Target Close (TC) and
Implementation Shortfall (IS) in the Almgren-Chriss framework. We explain how
to compute the optimal starting and stopping times for IS and TC, respectively,
given a minimum trading size. We also show how to add a minimum participation
rate constraint (Percentage of Volume, PVol) for both TC and IS. We also study
an alternative set of risk measures for the optimisation of algorithmic trading
curves. We assume a self-similar process (e.g.
We analyze a controlled price formation experiment in the laboratory that
shows evidence for bubbles. We calibrate two models that demonstrate with high
statistical significance that these laboratory bubbles have a tendency to grow
faster than exponential due to positive feedback. We show that the positive
feedback operates by traders continuously upgrading their over-optimistic
expectations of future returns based on past prices rather than on realized
returns.
Proportional transaction costs present difficult theoretical problems in
trading algorithm design, on account of their lack of analytical tractability.
The author derives a solution of DT-NT-DT form for an arbitrary model in which
the the traded asset has diffusive dynamics described by one or more stochastic
risk factors. The width of the NT zone is found to be, as expected,
proportional to the cube root of the transaction cost.
This paper focuses on an extension of the Limit Order Book (LOB) model with
general shape introduced by Alfonsi, Fruth and Schied. Here, the additional
feature allows a time-varying LOB depth. We solve the optimal execution problem
in this framework for both discrete and continuous time strategies. This gives
in particular sufficient conditions to exclude Price Manipulations in the sense
of Huberman and Stanzl or Transaction-Triggered Price Manipulations (see
Alfonsi, Schied and Slynko).
Assuming geometric Brownian motion as unaffected price process $S^0$,
Gatheral & Schied (2011) derived a strategy for optimal order execution that
reacts in a sensible manner on market changes but can still be computed in
closed form. Here we will investigate the robustness of this strategy with
respect to misspecification of the law of $S^0$. We prove the surprising result
that the strategy remains optimal whenever $S^0$ is a square-integrable
martingale.
We give a complete solution to the problem of minimizing the expected
liquidity costs in presence of a general drift when the underlying market
impact model has linear transient price impact with exponential resilience. It
turns out that this problem is well-posed only if the drift is absolutely
continuous. Optimal strategies often do not exist, and when they do, they
depend strongly on the derivative of the drift.
I derive asymptotic distribution of the bids/offers as a function of
proportion between patient and impatient traders using my modification of
Foucault, Kadan and Kandel dynamic Limit Order Book (LOB) model. Distribution
of patient and impatient traders asymptotically obeys rather simple PDE, which
admits numerical solutions. My modification of LOB model allows stylized but
sufficiently realistic representation of the trading markets. In particular,
dynamic LOB allows simulating the distribution of execution times and spreads
from high-frequency quotes.
A limit order book provides information on available limit order prices and
their volumes. Based on these quantities, we give an empirical result on the
relationship between the bid-ask liquidity balance and trade sign and we show
that liquidity balance on best bid/best ask is quite informative for predicting
the future market order's direction. Moreover, we define price jump as a sell
(buy) market order arrival which is executed at a price which is smaller
(larger) than the best bid (best ask) price at the moment just after the
precedent market order arrival.
We study the optimal liquidation problem using limit orders. Albeit the
seminal literature on optimal liquidation, rooted to Almgren-Chriss models,
tackles the optimal liquidation problem using a trade-off between market impact
and price risk, it only answers the general question of the liquidation rhythm.
The very question of the actual way to proceed with trading is then rarely
dealt with since most classical models use only market orders. Our model, that
incorporates both price risk and non-execution risk, answers this question
using optimal placement of limit orders.
We propose a model for the dynamics of a limit order book in a liquid market
where buy and sell orders are submitted at high frequency. We derive a
functional central limit theorem for the joint dynamics of the bid and ask
queues and show that, when the frequency of order arrivals is large, the
intraday dynamics of the limit order book may be approximated by a Markovian
jump-diffusion process in the positive orthant, whose characteristics are
explicitly described in terms of the statistical properties of the underlying
order flow.
We present a simple microstructure model of financial returns that combines
(i) the well-known ARFIMA process applied to tick-by-tick returns, (ii) the
bid-ask bounce effect, (iii) the fat tail structure of the distribution of
returns and (iv) the non-Poissonian statistics of inter-trade intervals. This
model allows us to explain both qualitatively and quantitatively important
stylized facts observed in the statistics of microstructure returns, including
the short-ranged correlation of returns, the long-ranged correlations of
absolute returns, the microstructure noise and Epps effects.
We demonstrate that a stochastic model consistent with the scaling properties
of financial assets is able to replicate the empirical statistical properties
of the S&P 500 high frequency data within a window of three hours in each
trading day. This result extends previous findings obtained for EUR/USD
exchange rates. We apply the forecast capabilities of the model to implement an
explicit trading strategy. Trading signals are model-based and not derived from
chartist criteria.
We describe a bottom-up framework, based on the identification of appropriate
order parameters and determination of phase diagrams, for understanding
progressively refined agent-based models and simulations of financial markets.
We illustrate this framework by starting with a deterministic toy model,
whereby $N$ independent traders buy and sell $M$ stocks through an order book
that acts as a clearing house. The price of a stock increases whenever it is
bought and decreases whenever it is sold. Price changes are updated by the
order book before the next transaction takes place.
We consider an illiquid financial market where a risk-averse investor has to
liquidate a large portfolio within a finite time horizon [0,T] and can trade
continuously at a traditional exchange (the "primary venue") and in a dark
pool. At the primary venue, trading yields a linear price impact. In the dark
pool, no price impact costs arise but order execution is uncertain, modeled by
a multi-dimensional Poisson process.
In this paper we analyze Gresham's Law, in particular, how the rate of inflow
or outflow of currencies is affected by the demand elasticity of arbitrage and
the difference in face value ratios inside and outside of a country under a
bimetallic system. We find that these equations are very similar to those used
to describe drift in systems of free charged particles. In addition, we look at
how Gresham's Law would play out with multiple currencies and multiple
countries under a variety of connecting topologies.
We introduce a prototype model in an attempt to capture some aspects of
market dynamics simulating a trading mechanism. The model description starts
with a discrete-space, continuous-time Markov process describing arrival and
movement of orders with different prices. We then perform a re-scaling
procedure leading to a deterministic dynamical system controlled by non-linear
ordinary differential equations (ODEs). This allows us to introduce
approximations for the equilibrium distribution of the model represented by
fixed points of deterministic dynamics.
We have studied the empirical distribution of cancellation positions through
rebuilding the limit-order book using the order flow data of 23 liquid stocks
traded on the Shenzhen Stock Exchange in the year 2003. We find that the
probability density function (PDF) of relative price levels where cancellations
allocate obeys the log-normal distribution. We then analyze the PDF of
normalized relative price levels by removing the factor of order numbers stored
at the price level, and find that the PDF has a power-law behavior in the tails
for both buy and sell orders.
Asset liquidity in modern financial markets is a key but elusive concept. A
market is often said to be liquid when the prevailing structure of transactions
provides a prompt and secure link between the demand and supply of assets, thus
delivering low costs of transaction. Providing a rigorous and empirically
relevant definition of market liquidity has, however, provided to be a
difficult task. This paper provides a critical review of the frameworks
currently available for modelling and estimating the market liquidity of
assets.
This paper presents a stochastic recursive procedure under constraints to
find the optimal distance at which an agent must post his order to minimize his
execution cost. We prove the $a.s.$ convergence of the algorithm under
assumptions on the cost function and give some practical criteria on model
parameters to ensure that the conditions to use the algorithm are fulfilled
(using notably principle of opposite monotony). We illustrate our results with
numerical experiments on simulated data but also by using a financial market
dataset.
We define a numerical method that provides a non-parametric estimation of the
kernel shape in symmetric multivariate Hawkes processes. This method relies on
second order statistical properties of Hawkes processes that relate the
covariance matrix of the process to the kernel matrix. The square root of the
correlation function is computed using a minimal phase recovering method. We
illustrate our method on some examples and provide an empirical study of the
estimation errors. Within this framework, we analyze high frequency financial
price data modeled as 1D or 2D Hawkes processes.
This paper aims at designing the different important components of a
semi-closed simulated stock market (pricing mechanism, stock allocation and
news generation). The purpose is to understand the interactions of the
different aspects within a 'semi-closed' system. The complexity and nature of
the system led to the process of modifying the pricing mechanism which is
viewed from a different angle to the classical Brownian Motion and the Random
Walk model.
We propose a flexible framework for profit-seeking market making by combining
cost function based automated market makers with bandit learning algorithms.
The key idea is to consider each parametrisation of the cost function as a
bandit arm, and the minimum expected profits from trades executed during a
period as the rewards. This allows for the creation of market makers that can
adjust liquidity and bid-asks spreads dynamically to maximise profits.
Lead/lag relationships are an important stylized fact at high frequency. Some
assets follow the path of others with a small time lag. We provide indicators
to measure this phenomenon using tick-by-tick data. Strongly asymmetric
cross-correlation functions are empirically observed, especially in the
future/stock case. We confirm the intuition that the most liquid assets (short
intertrade duration, narrow bid/ask spread, small volatility, high turnover)
tend to lead smaller stocks. However, the most correlated stocks are those with
similar levels of liquidity.
We consider the optimal trade execution strategies for a large portfolio of
single stocks proposed by Almgren (2003). This framework accounts for a
nonlinear impact of trades on average market prices. The results of Almgren
(2003) are based on the assumption that no shares of assets per unit of time
are trade at the beginning of the period. We propose a general solution method
that accomodates the case of a positive stock of assets in the initial period.
Our findings are twofold.
We consider a single security market based on a limit order book and two
investors, with different speeds of trade execution. If the fast investor can
front-run the slower investor, we show that this allows the fast trader to
obtain risk free profits, but that these profits cannot be scaled. We derive
the fast trader's optimal behaviour when she has only distributional knowledge
of the slow trader's actions, with few restrictions on the possible prior
distributions.
The asymmetric price impact between the institutional purchases and sales of
32 liquid stocks in Chinese stock markets in year 2003 is carefully studied. We
analyze the price impact in both drawup and drawdown trends with consecutive
positive and negative daily price changes, and test the dependence of the price
impact asymmetry on the market condition. For most of the stocks institutional
sales have a larger price impact than institutional purchases, and larger
impact of institutional purchases only exists in few stocks with primarily
increasing tendencies.
Manipulation is an important issue for both developed and emerging stock
markets. For the study of manipulation, it is critical to analyze investor
behavior in the stock market. In this paper, an analysis of the full
transaction records of over a hundred stocks in a one-year period is conducted.
For each stock, a trading network is constructed to characterize the relations
among its investors.
In financial markets, abnormal trading behaviors pose a serious challenge to
market surveillance and risk management. What is worse, there is an increasing
emergence of abnormal trading events that some experienced traders constitute a
collusive clique and collaborate to manipulate some instruments, thus mislead
other investors by applying similar trading behaviors for maximizing their
personal benefits.
In financial markets, liquidity is not constant over time but exhibits strong
seasonal patterns. In this article we consider a limit order book model that
allows for time-dependent, deterministic depth and resilience of the book and
determine optimal portfolio liquidation strategies. In a first model variant,
we propose a trading dependent spread that increases when market orders are
matched against the order book. In this model no price manipulation occurs and
the optimal strategy is of the wait region - buy region type often encountered
in singular control problems.
In this paper we apply a new approach of the string theory to the real
financial market. The strings are defined here by the boundary conditions,
characteristic length, real values and the method of redistribution of
information. The map represents the detrending and data standardization
procedure. We used 1-end-point, 2-end-point open string and partially
compactified strings that satisfy the Dirichlet and Neumann boundary
conditions. We established two different models to predict the behavior of
financial forex market.
Enlargement of filtrations is a classical topic in the general theory of
stochastic processes. This theory has been applied to stochastic finance in
order to analyze models with insider information. In this paper we study
initial enlargement in a Markov chain market model, introduced by R. Norberg.
In the enlargened filtration several things can happen: some of the jumps times
can be accessible or predictable, but in the orginal filtration all the jumps
times are totally inaccessible.
Equity order flow is persistent in the sense that buy orders tend to be
followed by buy orders and sell orders tend to be followed by sell orders. For
equity order flow this persistence is extremely long-ranged, with positive
correlations spanning thousands of orders, over time intervals of up to several
days. Such persistence in supply and demand is economically important because
it influences the market impact as a function of both time and size and because
it indicates that the market is in a sense out of equilibrium.
We introduce a new general framework for constructing the best trading
strategy for a given historical indicator. We construct the unique trading
strategy with the highest expected return. This optimal strategy may be
implemented directly, or its expected return may be used as a benchmark to
evaluate how far away from the optimal other proposed strategies for the given
indicators are. Separately, we also construct the unique trading strategy with
the highest information ratio.
We consider idealized financial markets in which price paths of the traded
securities are cadlag functions, imposing mild restrictions on the allowed size
of jumps. We prove the existence of quadratic variation for typical price
paths, where the qualification "typical" means that there is a trading strategy
that risks only one monetary unit and brings infinite capital if quadratic
variation does not exist. This result allows one to apply numerous known
results in pathwise Ito calculus to typical price paths; we give a brief
overview of such results.
We propose a general framework to describe the impact of different events in
the order book, that generalizes previous work on the impact of market orders.
Two different modeling routes can be considered, which are equivalent when only
market orders are taken into account. One model posits that each event type has
a temporary impact (TIM).
We study an optimal execution problem in a market model which considers
market impact. First we study a discrete-time model and describe a value
function. Then, by shortening the intervals of the execution times, we derive
the value function of a continuous-time model and study some of its properties
(continuity, semi-group property and viscosity property). We show that these
vary with the strength of the market impact. We introduce some examples which
show that the forms of the optimal strategies change completely, depending on
the amount of the trader's security holdings.
We study the optimal execution problem in the presence of market impact and
give a generalization of the main result of Kato(2009). Then we consider an
example where the security price follows a geometric Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process
which has the so-called mean-reverting property, and then show that an optimal
strategy is a mixture of initial/terminal block liquidation and intermediate
gradual liquidation.
In this paper the problem of optimal derivative design, profit maximization
and risk minimization under adverse selection when multiple agencies compete
for the business of a continuum of heterogenous agents is studied. The presence
of ties in the agents' best-response correspondences yields discontinuous
payoff functions for the agencies. These discontinuities are dealt with via
efficient tie--breaking rules.
This paper highlights the role of risk neutral investors in generating
endogenous bubbles in derivatives markets. We propose the following theorem. A
market for derivatives, which has all the features of a perfect market except
completeness and has some risk neutral investors, may exhibit almost surely
extreme price movements which represent a violation to the Gaussian random walk
hypothesis. This can be viewed as a paradox because it contradicts wide-held
conjectures about prices in informationally efficient markets with rational
investors.
We propose a framework for studying optimal market making policies in a limit
order book (LOB). The bid-ask spread of the LOB is modelled by a Markov chain
with finite values, multiple of the tick size, and subordinated by the Poisson
process of the tick-time clock. We consider a small agent who continuously
submits limit buy/sell orders and submits market orders at discrete dates. The
objective of the market maker is to maximize her expected utility from revenue
over a short term horizon by a tradeoff between limit and market orders, while
controlling her inventory position.
This paper addresses the optimal scheduling of the liquidation of a portfolio
using a new angle. Instead of focusing only on the scheduling aspect like
Almgren and Chriss, or only on the liquidity-consuming orders like Obizhaeva
and Wang, we link the optimal trade-schedule to the price of the limit orders
that have to be sent to the limit order book to optimally liquidate a
portfolio. Most practitioners address these two issues separately: they compute
an optimal trading curve and they then send orders to the markets to try to
follow it.
As demonstrated during the recent financial crisis, regulators require
additional analytical tools to assess systemic risk in the financial sector.
This paper describes one such tool; namely a novel market modeling and analysis
capability. Our model builds upon two leading market models: one which
emphasizes market micro-structure and another which emphasizes an ecology of
trading strategies. We address a limitation of market modeling, namely the
consideration of only one dominant trading strategy (i.e., long positions).
Market makers have to continuously set bid and ask quotes for the stocks they
have under consideration. Hence they face a complex optimization problem in
which their return, based on the bid-ask spread they quote and the frequency
they indeed provide liquidity, is challenged by the price risk they bear due to
their inventory. In this paper, we provide optimal bid and ask quotes and
closed-form approximations are derived using spectral arguments.
In this paper, we present a multi-period trading model by assuming that
traders face not only asymmetric information but also heterogenous prior
beliefs, under the requirement that the insider publicly disclose his stock
trades after the fact. We show that there is an equilibrium in which the
irrational insider camouflages his trades with a noise component so that his
private information is revealed slowly and linearly whenever he is
overconfident or underconfident.
We study a bargaining scheme under which two agents update their beliefs
about the future states of the world in order to reach an agreement on the
price of a given contingent claim. We first formulate the problem as an
optimization problem and prove the existence of a solution for such problem
yielding a unique price for the contingent claim to be traded.
We propose a dynamical theory of market liquidity that predicts that the
average supply/demand profile is V-shaped and {\it vanishes} around the current
price. This result is generic, and only relies on mild assumptions about the
order flow and on the fact that prices are (to a first approximation)
diffusive. This naturally accounts for two striking stylized facts: first,
large metaorders have to be fragmented in order to be digested by the liquidity
funnel, leading to long-memory in the sign of the order flow.
We consider a framework for solving optimal liquidation problems in limit
order books. In particular, order arrivals are modeled as a point process whose
intensity depends on the liquidation price. We set up a stochastic control
problem in which the goal is to maximize the expected revenue from liquidating
the entire position held. We solve this optimal liquidation problem for
power-law and exponential-decay order book models and discuss several
extensions. We also consider the continuous selling (or fluid) limit when the
trading units are ever smaller and the intensity is ever larger.
We propose and study a simple stochastic model for the dynamics of a limit
order book, in which arrivals of market order, limit orders and order
cancellations are described in terms of a Markovian queueing system. Through
its analytical tractability, the model allows to obtain analytical expressions
for various quantities of interest such as the distribution of the duration
between price changes, the distribution and autocorrelation of price changes,
and the probability of an upward move in the price, {\it conditional} on the
state of the order book.
We present an empirical study of the intertwined behaviour of members in a
financial market. Exploiting a database where the broker that initiates an
order book event can be identified, we decompose the correlation and response
functions into contributions coming from different market participants and
study how their behaviour is interconnected. We find evidence that (1) brokers
are very heterogeneous in liquidity provision -- some are consistently
liquidity providers while others are consistently liquidity takers.
This paper examines the intra-day seasonality of transacted limit and market
orders in the DEM/USD foreign exchange market. Empirical analysis of completed
transactions data based on the Dealing 2000-2 electronic inter-dealer broking
system indicates significant evidence of intraday seasonality in returns and
return volatilities under usual market conditions. Moreover, analysis of
realised tail outcomes supports seasonality for extraordinary market conditions
across the trading day.
A mean-reverting financial instrument is optimally traded by buying it when
it is sufficiently below the estimated `mean level' and selling it when it is
above. In the presence of linear transaction costs, a large amount of value is
paid away crossing bid-offers unless one devises a `buffer' through which the
price must move before a trade is done.
We study a single risky financial asset model subject to price impact and
transaction cost over an finite time horizon. An investor needs to execute a
long position in the asset affecting the price of the asset and possibly
incurring in fixed transaction cost. The objective is to maximize the
discounted revenue obtained by this transaction. This problem is formulated as
an impulse control problem and we characterize the value function using the
viscosity solutions framework.
This paper analyzes the dynamic incentives for technology adoption under a
transferable permits system, which allows for strategic trading on the permit
market. Initially, firms can invest both in low-emitting production
technologies and trade permits. In the model, technology adoption and allowance
price are generated endogenously and are inter-dependent.
Buying or selling assets leads to transaction costs for the investor. On one
hand, it is well know to all market practionaires that the transaction costs
are positive on average and present therefore systematic loss. On the other
hand, for every trade, there is a buy side and a sell side, the total amount of
asset and the total amount of cash is conserved. I show, that the apparently
paradoxical observation of systematic loss of all participants is intrinsic to
the trading process since it corresponds to a correlation of outstanding orders
and price changes.
This paper conducts an empirically study on the trade package composed of a
sequence of consecutive purchases or sales of 23 stocks in Chinese stock
market. We investigate the probability distributions of the execution time, the
number of trades and the total trading volume of trade packages, and analyze
the possible scaling relations between them. Quantitative differences are
observed between the institutional and individual investors.
In this paper, we present a multi-period trading model in the style of Kyle
(1985)'s inside trading model, by assuming that there are at least two insiders
in the market with long-lived private information, under the requirement that
each insider publicly discloses his stock trades after the fact. Based on this
model, we study the influences of "public disclosure" and "competition among
insiders" on the trading behaviors of insiders.
We develop a theory for the market impact of large trading orders, which we
call metaorders because they are typically split into small pieces and executed
incrementally. Market impact is empirically observed to be a concave function
of metaorder size, i.e. the impact per share of large metaorders is smaller
than that of small metaorders. Within a framework in which informed traders are
competitive we derive a fair pricing condition, which says that the average
transaction price of the metaorder is equal to the price after trading is
completed.
We study a variation of the minority game. There are N agents. Each has to
choose between one of two alternatives everyday, and there is reward to each
member of the smaller group. The agents cannot communicate with each other, but
try to guess the choice others will make, based only the past history of number
of people choosing the two alternatives. We describe a simple probabilistic
strategy using which the agents acting independently, can still maximize the
average number of people benefitting every day.
We empirically study the trading activity in the electronic on-book segment
and in the dealership off-book segment of the London Stock Exchange,
investigating separately the trading of active market members and of other
market participants which are non-members.
We introduce a new stochastic model for the variations of asset prices at the
tick-by-tick level in dimension 1 (for a single asset) and 2 (for a pair of
assets). The construction is based on marked point processes and relies on
linear self and mutually exciting stochastic intensities as introduced by
Hawkes. We associate a counting process with the positive and negative jumps of
an asset price. By coupling suitably the stochastic intensities of upward and
downward changes of prices for several assets simultaneously, we can reproduce
microstructure noise (i.e.
We present an overview of some representative Agent-Based Models in
Economics. We discuss why and how agent-based models represent an important
step in order to explain the dynamics and the statistical properties of
financial markets beyond the Classical Theory of Economics.
Kyle (1985) builds a pioneering and influential model, in which an insider
with long-lived private information submits an optimal order in each period
given the market maker's pricing rule. An inconsistency exists to some extent
in the sense that the ``constant pricing rule " actually assumes an adaptive
expected price with pricing rule given before insider making the decision, and
the ``market efficiency" condition, however, assumes a rational expected price
and implies that the pricing rule can be influenced by insider's strategy.
As the pricing mechanism in more than half the world's financial markets, the
limit order book has recently been the focus of a great deal of published
literature in a wide range of disciplines. In this survey, we present a
mathematical description of the price matching algorithm at the heart of limit
order trading, and highlight some of the key publications - both empirical and
theoretical - that have advanced understanding of the process to date.
We study the price impact of order book events - limit orders, market orders
and cancelations - using the NYSE TAQ data for 50 U.S. stocks. We show that,
over short time intervals, price changes are mainly driven by the order flow
imbalance, defined as the imbalance between supply and demand at the best bid
and ask prices. Our study reveals a linear relation between order flow
imbalance and price changes, with a slope inversely proportional to the market
depth. These results are shown to be robust to seasonality effects, and stable
across time scales and across stocks.
A detailed analysis of correlation between stock returns at high frequency is
compared with simple models of random walks. We focus in particular on the
dependence of correlations on time scales - the so-called Epps effect. This
provides a characterization of stochastic models of stock price returns which
is appropriate at very high frequency.
Statistical properties of double-auction markets with Bid-Ask spread in
market order are investigated through the response function. We first attempt
to utilize the so-called Madhavan-Richardson-Roomans model (MRR for short) to
simulate the stochastic process of the price-change in empirical data sets
(say, EUR/JPY or USD/JPY exchange rates) in which the Bid-Ask spread fluctuates
in time. We find that the MRR theory apparently fails to simulate so much as
the qualitative behaviour (`non-monotonic' behaviour) of the response function
calculated from the data.
We present a mathematical study of the order book as a multidimensional
continuous-time Markov chain where the order flow is modelled by independent
Poisson processes. Our aim is to bridge the gap between the microscopic
description of price formation (agent-based modelling), and the Stochastic
Differential Equations approach used classically to describe price evolution in
macroscopic time scales. To do this we rely on the theory of infinitesimal
generators. We motivate our approach using an elementary example where the
spread is kept constant ("perfect market making").
By studying all the trades and best bids/asks of ultra high frequency
snapshots recorded from the order books of a basket of 10 futures assets, we
bring qualitative empirical evidence that the impact of a single trade depends
on the intertrade time lags. We find that when the trading rate becomes faster,
the return variance per trade or the impact, as measured by the price variation
in the direction of the trade, strongly increases. We provide evidence that
these properties persist at coarser time scales. We also show that the spread
value is an increasing function of the activity.
We study two kinds of economic exchange, additive and multiplicative, in a
system of N agents. The work is divided in two parts, in the first one, the
agents are free to interact with each other. The system evolves to a
Boltzmann-Gibbs distribution with additive exchange and condenses with a
multiplicative one. If bankruptcy is introduced, both types of exchange lead to
condensation. Condensation times have been studied. In the second part, the
agents are placed in a social network.
In this paper we introduce a simple model for a financial market
characterized by a single stock or good and an interplay between two different
traders populations, chartists and fundamentalists, which determine the price
dynamic of the stock. The model has been inspired by the microscopic
Lux-Marchesi model (T.Lux, M.Marchesi, Nature 397, (1999), 498--500). The
introduction of kinetic equations permits to study the asymptotic behavior of
the investments and the price distributions and to characterize the regimes of
lognormal behavior and the formation of power law tails.
We study the informational efficiency of a market with a single traded asset.
The price initially differs from the fundamental value, about which the agents
have noisy private information (which is, on average, correct). A fraction of
traders revise their price expectations in each period. The price at which the
asset is traded is public information. The agents' expectations have an
adaptive component and a social-interactions component with confirmatory bias.
We show that, taken separately, each of the deviations from rationality worsen
the information efficiency of the market.
We consider a heterogeneous agent-based economic model where economic agents
have strictly bounded rationality and where income allocation strategies evolve
through selective imitation. Income is calculated by a Cobb-Douglas type
production function, and selection of strategies for imitation depends on the
income growth rate they generate. We show that under these conditions, when an
agent adopts a new strategy, the effect on its income growth rate is
immediately visible to other agents, which allows a group of imitating agents
to quickly adapt their strategies when needed.
Ensuring sufficient liquidity is one of the key challenges for designers of
prediction markets. Various market making algorithms have been proposed in the
literature and deployed in practice, but there has been little effort to
evaluate their benefits and disadvantages in a systematic manner. We introduce
a novel experimental design for comparing market structures in live trading
that ensures fair comparison between two different microstructures with the
same trading population.
We study how information perturbations can destabilize two-sided matching
markets. In our model, agents arrive on the market over two periods, while
agents in the first period do not know the types of those arriving later.
Agents already present in the market may match early or wait for the small
group of new entrants. Despite the lack of discounting or risk aversion, this
perturbation creates incentives to match early and leave the market before the
new agents arrive.
Using frequency distributions of daily closing price sequences of several
stock markets, we investigate whether the bias away from an equiprobable
sequence distribution, predicted by algorithmic probability, may account for
some of the deviation of financial markets from log-normal, and if so for how
much of said deviation and over what sequence lengths. Our discussion might
constitute a potential starting point for a further investigation of the market
as a rule-based system with an 'algorithmic' component, despite its apparent
randomness.
In a financial market, for agents with long investment horizons or at times
of severe market stress, it is often changes in the asset price that act as the
trigger for transactions or shifts in investment position. This suggests the
use of price thresholds to simulate agent behavior over much longer timescales
than are currently used in models of order-books.
We show that many phenomena, routinely ignored in efficient market theory,
can be systematically introduced into an otherwise efficient market, resulting
in models that robustly replicate the most important stylized facts.
Addressing the ongoing controversy over aggressive high-frequency trading
practices in financial markets, we report the results of an extensive empirical
study estimating the maximum possible profitability of such practices, and
arrive at figures that are surprisingly modest. Our findings highlight the
tension between execution costs and trading horizon confronted by
high-frequency traders, and provide a controlled and large-scale empirical
perspective on the high-frequency debate that has heretofore been absent.
Traditional market makers are losing their importance as automated systems
have largely assumed the role of liquidity provision in markets. We update the
model of Glosten and Milgrom (1985) to analyze this new world: we add multiple
securities and introduce an automated market maker who uses the relationships
between securities to price order flow. This new automated participant
transacts the majority of orders, sets prices that are more efficient, and
increases informed and decreases uninformed traders' transaction costs.
We study a single risky financial asset model subject to price impact and
transaction cost over an infinite horizon. An investor needs to execute a long
position in the asset affecting the price of the asset and possibly incurring
in a fixed transaction cost. The objective is to maximize the discounted
revenue obtained by this transactions. This problem is formulated first as an
impulse control problem and we characterize the value function using the
viscosity solutions framework.
Using high-frequency time series of stock prices and share volumes sizes from
January 2002-May 2009, this paper investigates whether the effects of the onset
of high-frequency trading, most prominent since 2005, are apparent in the
dynamics of the dollar traded volume. Indeed it is found in almost all of 14
heavily traded stocks, that there has been an increase in the Hurst exponent of
dollar traded volume from Gaussian noise in the earlier years to more
self-similar dynamics in later years.
The possibility that the collective dynamics of a set of stocks could lead to
a specific basket violating the efficient market hypothesis is investigated.
Precisely, we show that it is systematically possible to form a basket with a
non-trivial autocorrelation structure when the examined time scales are at the
order of tens of seconds. Moreover, we show that this situation is persistent
enough to allow some kind of forecasting.
Kinetic exchange models have been successful in explaining the shape of the
income/wealth distribution in the economies. However, such models usually make
some ad-hoc assumptions when it comes to determining the savings factor. Here,
we examine a few models in and out of the domain of standard neo-classical
economics to explain the savings behavior of the agents. A number of new
results are derived and the rest conform with those obtained earlier.
Connections are established between the reinforcement choice and strategic
choice models with the usual kinetic exchange models.
This paper proposes a parametric approach for stochastic modeling of limit
order markets. The models are obtained by augmenting classical perfectly liquid
market models by few additional risk factors that describe liquidity properties
of the order book. The resulting models are easy to calibrate and to analyze
using standard techniques for multivariate stochastic processes. Despite their
simplicity, the models are able to capture several properties that have been
found in microstructural analysis of limit order markets.
The gauge theory of arbitrage was introduced by Ilinski in
[arXiv:hep-th/9710148] and applied to fast money flows in
[arXiv:cond-mat/9902044]. The theory of fast money flow dynamics attempts to
model the evolution of currency exchange rates and stock prices on short, e.g.\
intra-day, time scales. It has been used to explain some of the heuristic
trading rules, known as technical analysis, that are used by professional
traders in the equity and foreign exchange markets.
We study the cascading dynamics immediately before and immediately after 219
market shocks. We define the time of a market shock T_{c} to be the time for
which the market volatility V(T_{c}) has a peak that exceeds a predetermined
threshold. The cascade of high volatility "aftershocks" triggered by the "main
shock" is quantitatively similar to earthquakes and solar flares, which have
been described by three empirical laws --- the Omori law, the productivity law,
and the Bath law. We analyze the most traded 531 stocks in U.S.
Motivated by the literature on investment flows and optimal trading, we
examine intraday predictability in the cross-section of stock returns. We find
a striking pattern of return continuation at half-hour intervals that are exact
multiples of a trading day, and this effect lasts for at least 40 trading days.
Volume, order imbalance, volatility, and bid-ask spreads exhibit similar
patterns, but do not explain the return patterns. We also show that short-term
return reversal is driven by temporary liquidity imbalances lasting less than
an hour and bid-ask bounce.
In the last decade, a large body of literature has been developed to explain
the universal features of inequality in terms of income and wealth. By now, it
is established that the distributions of income and wealth in various economies
show a number of statistical regularities. There are several models to explain
such static features of inequality in an unifying framework and the kinetic
exchange models, in particular, provide one such framework. Here we focus on
the dynamic features of inequality.
We show that the statistics of spreads in real order books is characterized
by an intrinsic asymmetry due to discreteness effects for even or odd values of
the spread. An analysis of data from the NYSE order book points out that
traders' strategies contribute to this asymmetry.
In the present work we introduce a novel multi-agent model with the aim to
reproduce the dynamics of a double auction market at microscopic time scale
through a faithful simulation of the matching mechanics in the limit order
book. The model follows a "zero intelligence" approach where the actions of the
traders are related to a stochastic variable, the market sentiment, which we
define as a mixture of public and private information.
We study a simple model of an asset market with informed and non-informed
agents. In the absence of non-informed agents, the market becomes information
efficient when the number of traders with different private information is
large enough. Upon introducing non-informed agents, we find that the latter
contribute significantly to the trading activity if and only if the market is
(nearly) information efficient.
Representative investors whose behaviour is modelled by a deterministic
finite automaton generate complexity both in the time series of each asset and
in the cross-sectional correlation when the rule governing their behaviour is
schizophrenic, meaning the investor must hold multiple seemingly contradictory
beliefs simultaneously, either by switching between two different rules at each
time step, or computing different responses to different assets.
We use techniques from network science to study correlations in the foreign
exchange (FX) market over the period 1991--2008. We consider an FX market
network in which each node represents an exchange rate and each weighted edge
represents a time-dependent correlation between the rates. To provide insights
into the clustering of the exchange rate time series, we investigate dynamic
communities in the network.
We seek to utilize the nonextensive statistics to the microscopic modeling of
the interacting many-investor dynamics that drive the price changes in a
market. The statistics of price changes are known to be fit well by the
Students-T and power-law distributions of the nonextensive statistics. We
therefore derive models of interacting investors that are based on the
nonextensive statistics and which describe the excess demand and formation of
price.
The goal of this article is to understand some interesting features of
sequences of arbitrage operations, which look relevant to various processes in
Economics and Finances. In the second part of the paper, analysis of sequences
of arbitrages is reformulated in the linear algebra terms. This admits an
elegant geometric interpretation of the problems under consideration linked to
the asynchronous systems theory. We feel that this interpretation will be
useful in understanding more complicated, and more realistic, mathematical
models in economics.
While the long-ranged correlation of market orders and their impact on prices
has been relatively well studied in the literature, the corresponding studies
of limit orders and cancellations are scarce. We provide here an empirical
study of the cross-correlation between all these different events, and their
respective impact on future price changes.
It has been suggested that marked point processes might be good candidates
for the modeling of financial high-frequency data. A special class of point
processes, Hawkes processes, has been the subject of various investigations in
the financial community. In this paper, we propose to enhance a basic order
book simulator with limit and market orders arrival times following mutually
(unsymmetrically) exciting Hawkes processes. Modeling is based on empirical
observations on interval times between orders that we verify on several markets
(equity, bond futures, index futures).
Large trades in a financial market are usually split into smaller parts and
traded incrementally over extended periods of time. We address these large
trades as hidden orders. In order to identify and characterize hidden orders we
fit hidden Markov models to the time series of the sign of the tick by tick
inventory variation of market members of the Spanish Stock Exchange. Our
methodology probabilistically detects trading sequences, which are
characterized by a net majority of buy or sell transactions.
In this paper we examine inefficiencies and information disparity in the
Japanese stock market. By carefully analysing information publicly available on
the internet, an `outsider' to conventional statistical arbitrage
strategies--which are based on market microstructure, company releases, or
analyst reports--can nevertheless pursue a profitable trading strategy. A large
volume of blog data is used to demonstrate the existence of an inefficiency in
the market. An information-based model that replicates the trading strategy is
developed to estimate the degree of information disparity.
We study the dynamics of order flows around large intraday price changes
using ultra-high-frequency data from the Shenzhen Stock Exchange. We find a
significant reversal of price for both intraday price decreases and increases
with a permanent price impact. The volatility, the volume of different types of
orders, the bid-ask spread, and the volume imbalance increase before the
extreme events and decay slowly as a power law, which forms a well-established
peak.
We observe the performances of three strategy evaluation schemes, which are
the history-dependent wealth game, the trend-opposing minority game, and the
trend-following majority game in a stock market where the price is exogenously
determined. The price is either directly adopted from the real stock market
indices or generated with the Markov chain of order $\le 2$. Each scheme's
success is quantified by average wealth accumulated by the traders equipped
with the scheme.
We study a simple exchange model in which price is fixed and the amount of a
good transferred between actors depends only on the actors' respective budgets
and the existence of a link between transacting actors. The model induces a
simply-connected but possibly multi-component bipartite graph. A trading
session on a fixed graph consists of a sequence of exchanges between connected
buyers and sellers until no more exchanges are possible. We deem a trading
session "feasible" if all of the buyers satisfy their respective demands.
A representative investor generates realistic and complex security price
paths by following this trading strategy: if, a few ticks ago, the market asset
had two consecutive upticks or two consecutive downticks, then sell, and
otherwise buy. This simple, unique, and robust model is the smallest possible
deterministic model of financial complexity, and its generalization leads to
complex variety. Compared to a random walk, the minimal model generates time
series with fatter tails and more frequent crashes, thus more closely matching
the real world.
Real world markets display power-law features in variables such as price
fluctuations in stocks. To further understand market behavior, we have
conducted a series of market experiments on our web-based prediction market
platform which allows us to reconstruct transaction networks among traders.
We consider optimal execution strategies for block market orders placed in a
limit order book (LOB). We build on the resilience model proposed by Obizhaeva
and Wang (2005) but allow for a general shape of the LOB defined via a given
density function. Thus, we can allow for empirically observed LOB shapes and
obtain a nonlinear price impact of market orders.
We introduce a new formulation of asset trading games in continuous time in
the framework of the game-theoretic probability established by Shafer and Vovk
(Probability and Finance: It's Only a Game! (2001) Wiley). In our formulation,
the market moves continuously, but an investor trades in discrete times, which
can depend on the past path of the market. We prove that an investor can
essentially force that the asset price path behaves with the variation exponent
exactly equal to two.
In a recent paper, Alfonsi, Fruth and Schied (AFS) propose a simple order
book based model for the impact of large orders on stock prices. They use this
model to derive optimal strategies for the execution of large orders. We apply
these strategies to an agent-based stochastic order book model that was
recently proposed by Bovier, \v{C}ern\'{y} and Hryniv, but already the
calibration fails. In particular, from our simulations the recovery speed of
the market after a large order is clearly dependent on the order size, whereas
the AFS model assumes a constant speed.
Motivated by how transaction amount constrain trading volume and price
volatility in stock market, we, in this paper, study the relation between
volume and price if amount of transaction is given. We find that accumulative
trading volume gradually emerges a kurtosis near the price mean value over a
trading price range when it takes a longer trading time, regardless of actual
price fluctuation path, time series, or total transaction volume in the time
interval.
We develop a theoretical trading conditioning model subject to price
volatility and return in terms of market psychological behavior, based on a
volume-price probability wave distribution in which we use transaction volume
probability to describe price volatility uncertainty and intensity.
Despite the availability of very detailed data on financial market,
agent-based modeling is hindered by the lack of information about real-trader
behavior. This makes it impossible to validate agent-based models, which are
thus reverse-engineering attempts. This work is a contribution to the building
of a set of stylized facts about the traders themselves. Using the client
database of Swissquote Bank SA, we find that the transaction cost structure
determines on average to a large extend the relationship between the mean
turnover per transaction of an investor and his mean wealth.
A dynamic herding model with interactions of trading volumes is introduced.
At time $t$, an agent trades with a probability, which depends on the ratio of
the total trading volume at time $t-1$ to its own trading volume at its last
trade. The price return is determined by the volume imbalance and number of
trades. The model successfully reproduces the power-law distributions of the
trading volume, number of trades and price return, and their relations.
Moreover, the generated time series are long-range correlated.
Evolutions of the trading landscape lead to the capability to exchange the
same financial instrument on different venues. Because liquidity issues the
trading firms split large orders across trading destinations to optimize their
execution. To solve this problem we devised two stochastic recursive learning
procedures which adjust the proportions of the order to be sent to the
different venues, one based on an optimization principle, the other on
reinforcement ideas. We investigate both procedures from a theoretical point of
view.
We contrast Arbitrage Pricing Theory (APT), the theoretical basis for the
development of financial instruments, with a dynamical picture of an
interacting market, in a simple setting. The proliferation of financial
instruments apparently provides more means for risk diversification, making the
market more efficient and complete.
We define a methodology to quantify market activity on a 24 hour basis by
defining a scale, the so-called scale of market quakes (SMQ). The SMQ is
designed within a framework where we analyse the dynamics of excess price moves
from one directional change of price to the next. We use the SMQ to quantify
the FX market and evaluate the performance of the proposed methodology at major
news announcements. The evolution of SMQ magnitudes from 2003 to 2009 is
analysed across major currency pairs.